Gotta Luv It Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop: Experience Authentic Italian Flavor in Wurtsboro

If you're on the hunt for a local gem that encapsulates the heart of Italian cuisine, look no further than Gotta Luv It Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop. Nestled in the charming town of Wurtsboro, New York, at 187 Kingston Ave, this delightful eatery has been satisfying cravings for over two decades. Renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza, hearty stromboli, and mouthwatering subs, Gotta Luv It delivers an experience that keeps families coming back time and time again.

What sets Gotta Luv It apart is not just the delectable food but the warmth of its service. Loyal patrons like Gina Roberts rave about the friendly staff and the immaculate cleanliness of the establishment, while the convenience of takeout adds a layer of practicality for those busy evenings. For those with a discerning palate, the pizza here has been hailed as among the best in the world by customers like Jonathan Albán, who insists that the unique flavor can't be replicated elsewhere.

One of the standout offerings is undoubtedly the infamous “Mama’s Slices”, which Juni Vega encourages newcomers to try. Describing their pizza as "always good and fresh," Juni emphasizes the reasonable prices, making this hidden gem accessible for anyone seeking quality food without breaking the bank. This sentiment is echoed by visitors like Tanker 2-8 CAV, who were captivated not only by the delicious pizza but also by the evident pride the staff takes in providing top-notch service.

And let's not overlook the rich array of sandwiches; both meat lovers and vegetarians can find something to delight their taste buds. Regulars like Joe LaMotta swear by the chicken cutlets, claiming they're the best outside of family kitchens. Such endorsements speak volumes about the commitment to authentic, homemade flavors that Gotta Luv It embodies.

With ample free parking and an inviting atmosphere, Gotta Luv It Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop is ideal for families, friends, and anyone craving a true taste of Italian culture. Whether you choose to dine in or opt for a convenient takeout order, this establishment promises a dining experience that you won’t soon forget. Join the ranks of satisfied customers and let Gotta Luv It become your go-to spot for pizza and more!

Has wheelchair-accessible car park

Offers kerbside pickup
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
No delivery

Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining

Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Gina Roberts

25/09/2025

My family and I have been eating here for over 20 years. Staff are friendly. Delicious Pizza, Stromboli and Subs. Very clean and well maintained. We also call in for take out pizza on evenings I don't feel like cooking. Plenty of free Parking.

Jonathan Albán

25/09/2025

These pizzas are the best in the world, I recommend them, I have eaten everything, I have been to many places and they do not have the same flavor.

Juni Vega

19/09/2025

For the location and size of this mom and pop pizza shop I have to say their pizza is always good, fresh, and the price point is more than reasonable. Get your pizza by the pie or the slice. If you haven’t tried the Mama’s Slices you don’t know what you’re missing!! I highly recommend this establishment to anyone who’s looking for good food at a reasonable price. And their service is also on point. Much respect to the entire Gotta Love It Pizza Family!!

Tanker 2-8 CAV

16/09/2025

This is one of those hidden gems. We were visiting from Florida and were craving some REAL NY style pizza. The pizza was out of this world delicious. The service was great even though they were super busy. It’s a small joint but you can tell the people take pride in their shop and it shows. If you ever come across this place I would highly recommend you stop in and get some delicious pizza.

Joe LaMotta

31/08/2025

Best Chicken Cutlets outside of my Mother's. Abe is the best, always making great food!

Veronica G

10/08/2025

My boyfriend is a chef so we don’t get take out a lot because he prefers to cook himself, he’s also super picky. We both were extremely impressed with the food here. We placed an order at 7:30 at night and everything tasted super fresh, they also didn’t do a rush job which a lot of places tend to do when they are closing soon . the portions were also huge. The penne vodka was the best I’ve ever had and he said his Philly cheese steak was amazing. They also were generous with the amount of bread they gave us without having to ask for extra. Prices are good too.

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *